| Year | Player | Institution | Affiliation |
| 2015-2016 | Hannah Moore | Sterling College | NAIA DI |
| Savannah Dungan | Colorado State | NCAA DI | |
| Brittany Gustin | Park University | NAIA DI | |
| 2014-2105 | Leslie Ford | Indiana Purdue of Calumet | NCAA DII |
| Justice Scales | Park Univerity | NAIA DI | |
| Bailey Letts | Austin Peay | NCAA DI | |
| 2013-2014 | Megan Dike | Bethel College | NAIA DII |
| Amanda Holroyd | Southwest Oklahoma State | NCAA DII | |
| Hanna Barnhart | Southwest Oklahoma State | NCAA DII | |
| 2012-2013 | Alyssa Lee | University of St. Mary | NAIA DII |
| Taylor Sherrill | Park University | NAIA DII | |
| Myrian Cisneros | Avila University | NAIA DII | |
| Cassie Morrison | Southwestern College | NAIA DI | |
| Hayla Demel | Kansas State University | NCAA DI | |
| 2011-2012 | Katie Cothran | University of Central Missouri | NCAA DII |
| Tiffany Jennings | University of Kansas | NCAA DI | |
| 2010-2011 | Jayme Foskett | Pittsburgh State University | NCAA DII |
| Keasla Hundley | University of St. Mary | NAIA DII | |
| Briannah Williams | Langston University | NAIA DI | |
| Jenyce Spence | Union University | NAIA DI | |
| 2009-2010 | Codi Schierbaum | Emporia State University | NCAA DII |
| Sarah Payan | University of Texas El Paso | NCAA DI |