1989-1990:
Stephanie Stean (3.81) - Track
1990-1991:
Errin Courtney (3.82) - Softball
Mary Rich (3.91) - Track and Field
1994-1995:
Kim Manthei (4.00) - Women's Basketball/Softball
Angela Fiatte (3.96) - Softball
Melissa Meek (3.76) - Softball
1995-1996:
Carlos Vasquez (3.67) - Cross Country
Nichole Haen (4.00) - Softball
Jamie Cordell (3.90) - Volleyball
Kevin O'Brien (3.93) - Golf
1996-1997:
James Hawkins (3.76) - Soccer
Joseph Wood (3.75) - Cross Country
Ryan Apgar (3.75) - Golf
Heather Horyna (3.70) - Women's Basketball
Kelsey Manthei (3.69) - Volleyball
Jil Sutulovich (3.64) - Softball
1997-1998:
Robert Ferguson (3.73) - Baseball
Jamie Clark (3.71) - Volleyball
Amanda Purdon (3.63) - Volleyball
1998-1999:
Josh Moulin (3.68) - Baseball
Stephanie Snyder (3.67) - Volleyball
2005-2006:
Mara Hoefer (3.61) - Women's Basketball - Academic All-American
2007-2008:
Hilary Johnson (3.83) - Women's Basketball - Distinguished Academic All-American
Courtney Simanowitz (3.82) - Softball - Distinguisehd Academic All-American
Rachel Oswald (3.61) - Softball - Academic All-American
2008-2009:
Kyle Koch (3.79) - Baseball - Academic All-American
Ashleigh Gallio (3.76) - Women's Basketball - Academic All-American
Caitlin Bowlin (3.73) - Softball - Academic All-American
Taryn Lane (3.7) - Women's Basketball - Academic All-American
Charisse Presley (3.67) - Volleyball - Academic All-American
Alexa McGrory (3.65) - Women's Basketball - Academic All-American
Derrick Howard (3.63) - Men's Basketball - Academic All-American
Gustavo Juarez (3.62) - Men's Basketball - Academic All-American
2009-2010:
Sarah Craft (3.86) - Women's Basketball - Distinguished Academic All-American
2010-2011:
Kevin Lysaught (3.96) - Men's Basketball - Superior Academic Achievement
Keasla Hondley (3.64) - Softball - Exemplary Academic Achievement
2011-2012:
Mikenna Greathouse (3.61) - Women's Basketball - Exemplary Academic Achievement
2012-2013:
Andrew Kreiling (3.9) - Baseball - Superior Academic Acheivement
Alexandria Blaurock (3.8) - Women's Basketball - Superior Academic Achievement
Leah Oehm (3.8) - Volleyball - Superior Academic Achievement
Chelsea Brewer (3.69) - Softball - Exemplary Academic Achievement