| Year | Athlete | Institution | Affiliation | ||
| 2023 | Gary Bess Jr. | Springfield College | NCAA DIII | ||
| Jalen Broyles | Life University | NAIA | |||
| Joshua Dames | Notre Dame College | NCAA DII | |||
| Bradley Lightbourne | Washburn University | NCAA DII | |||
| Jerry Maxinaud | Lemoyne Owen College | NCAA DII | |||
| Jeremiah Stanton | Emporia State University | NCAA DII | |||
| 2022 | Bryce Johnson | Missouri Baptist University | NAIA | ||
| Keondre Brown | University of Antelope Valley | NAIA | |||
| Shayon Janloo | Southwestern Christian University | NAIA | |||
| 2021 | Robert Rhodes | Park University | NAIA | ||
| Cody Dortch | Park University | NAIA | |||
| Caleb Jones McCray | MidAmerica Nazarene University | NAIA | |||
| 2020 | Jalen Davis | UT Tyler Texas | NCAA DII | ||
| Savon Witt | UT Texas Rio Grande Valley | NCAA DI | |||
| Calvin Slaughter | Allen University | NCAA DII | |||
| 2017 | Jon Murray | Pittsburg State | NCAA DII | ||
| Kellan Turner | Mid America Nazerne | NAIA DI | |||
| Donald Metoyer Jr. | Grand View University | NAIA DI | |||
| Mike Lee Jr. | McRae College | NCAA DII | |||
| 2016 | Joe Lendway | Alaska-Ancorage | NCAA DII | ||
| 2015 | Curtis Vallejo | Benedictine College | NAIA DI | ||
| Anthony Ridley | Avila University | NAIA DII | |||
| Babajide Aina | Southern Arkansas University | NCAA DII | |||
| Clay Young | University of Kansas | NCAA DI | |||
| 2013 | Jordan Banks | Northern Arizona University | NCAA DI | ||
| 2012 | Brandon Morris | University of Houston | NCAA DI | ||
| Zach Bush | University of Central Missouri | NCAA DII | |||
| 2011 | Dennis Tinnon | Marshall University | NCAA DI | ||
| Kevin Lysaught | Baker University | NAIA DI | |||
| Kyle Sloan | Southwest Baptist University | NCAA DII | |||
| 2010 | Derrick Denny | Jacksonville State University | NCAA DI | ||
| Melvin Gaton | Park University | NAIA DI | |||
| Andre Metoyer | Rockhurst University | NCAA DII | |||
| Scott Fruehling | Columbia University | NAIA DI | |||
| Hal Payne | Columbia University | NAIA DI | |||
| Jonathon Wright | Missouri Western University | NCAA DII | |||
| 2009 | Derrick Howard | Park University | NAIA DI | ||
| Travis Fairley | Park University | NAIA DI | |||
| Jack Shortell | Baker University | NAIA DI | |||
| John Hale | University of St. Mary | NAIA DII | |||
| Josh Grayson | University of St. Mary | NAIA DII | |||
| Gus Juarez | University of Monterrey | Mexico | |||
| 2008 | Dust Burdolski | Emporia State University | NCAA DII | ||
| 2007 | David Nurse | Western Illinois | NCAA DI | ||
| Mike Sylvara | Missouri Western University | NCAA DII | |||
| Joe Hutchingson | Lincoln University | NCAA DII | |||
| Ryan Spearman | Lincoln University | NCAA DII | |||
| Eric Nitsche | University of St. Mary | NAIA DII | |||
| Kamrik Lamont | University of St. Mary | NAIA DII | |||
| 2006 | Mike Hutchingson | Pittsburg State University | NCAA DII | ||
| Roger Price | Upper Iowa University | NCAA DII | |||
| Malik Powell | University of Rutgers-Newark | NCAA DII | |||
| Brent Lierz | Emporia State University | NCAA DII | |||
| Mike Koch | Park University | NAIA DI | |||
| 2005 | Jason Jemison | Southwest Baptist University | NCAA DII | ||
| Prentes Potts | Southwest Baptist University | NCAA DII | |||
| Kelly Byrne | St. Cloud State | NCAA DII | |||
| Griffin Warren | Culver-Stockton | NAIA DII | |||
| Terry Menefee | Farmingdale College | NCAA DIII | |||
| 2004 | Greg Wells | Rockhurst University | NCAA DII | ||
| Nathan Winslow | Rockhurst University | NCAA DII | |||
| Anthony Stewart | Missouri Valley | NAIA | |||
| 2003 | Damione Liddell | New Hampshire University | NCAA DI | ||
| Craig Walls | New Hampshire University | NCAA DI | |||
| Stephone Washington | Georgia State University | NCAA DI | |||
| 2002 | Darien Chavis | Colorado State U. | NCAA DI | ||
| Kevin Mitchem | U. of Chicago - Illinois | NCAA DI | |||
| Solomon Bass | St. Mary - Texas | NCAA DII | |||
| Cameron Beldon | Wichita State University | NCAA DI | |||
| Luther Glover | Jamestown - North Dakota | NAIA | |||
| 2001 | Marcus Rosser | Montana State U. | NCAA DI | ||
| Rhasheed Peterson | University of Albany | NCAA DI | |||
| Mike Stevenson | Dakota Wesleyan | NAIA | |||
| John McDougald | U. of New Haven | NCAA DII | |||
| Dewayne Spencer | U. of Texas - Arlington | NCAA DI | |||
| Evan Cleaver | Dilliar University | NAIA | |||
| 2000 | Lewis Harrison | University of Kansas | NCAA DI | ||
| 1999 | Robert Watson | Western Michigan | NCAA DI | ||
| Bill Templeton | Concordia College | NCAA DII | |||
| Dacy Corlee | Park College | NAIA | |||
| Curtis Vignery | Park College | NAIA | |||
| Jay Dodder | Iowa Wesleyan | NAIA | |||
| 1998 | Matt Schurman | Ottawa University | NAIA | ||
| Brad Cleaver | Moreland State University | NCAA DI | |||
| Joey Smith | Campbell (North Carolina) | NCAA DI | |||
| Shaun Wilson | West Virginia State | NCAA DII | |||
| Arde Fuller | Avila | NAIA | |||
| Marcus Smith | UNLV | NCAA DI | |||
| Rodney Towles | Defiance College | NCAA DIII | |||
| 1997 | Sebastian King | Emporia State University | NCAA DII | ||
| Tay Officer | Park College | NAIA | |||
| Martin Shetlar | Friends University | NAIA | |||
| LaMont Dawkims | Benedictine College | NAIA | |||
| Jeremy Smith | Oakland University | NCAA DI | |||
| Jamie Bell | University of Colorado (Colo Spgs.) | NCAA DII | |||
| Tony Vega | Peru State | NAIA | |||
| 1996 | Charles Parks | UMKC | NCAA DI | ||
| Kedric Smith | University of North Carolina (Charlotte) | NCAA DI | |||
| Corey Smith | Pittsburg State University | NCAA DII | |||
| Brendon Lipton | Sam Houston State | NCAA DI | |||
| John Grubaugh | Youngstown State | NCAA DI | |||
| Jason Tarr | Iowa Wesleyan | NAIA | |||
| 1995 | Mike Johnson | William Penn (Iowa) | NCAA DIII | ||
| Chris Lewis | Park College | NAIA | |||
| DeMeeko Walsh | South Dakota State | NCAA DI | |||
| Ray Smith | Central Missouri | NCAA DII | |||
| 1994 | Brian Scott | Emporia State University | NCAA DII | ||
| Walter Hubain | Park College | NAIA | |||
| Frank Boswell | Washburn University | NCAA DII | |||
| 1993 | Robert Cherne | University of Arkansas - Little Rock | NCAA DI | ||
| Darryl Stewart | Rockhurst University | NCAA DII | |||
| Evan Jones | Assumption College | NCAA DII | |||
| 1992 | Henry Thomas | Lamar University | NCAA DI | ||
| Jeff Kahns | Kansas Wesleyan | NAIA | |||
| Sam Lars | Lincoln University | NCAA DII | |||
| Shawn Dent | Lincoln University | NCAA DII | |||
| Brandon Walker | Lincoln University | NCAA DII | |||
| 1991 | Steve Hooks | McNeese State | NCAA DI | ||
| Al McMillan | University of Cincinnati | NCAA DI | |||
| Todd Johnson | Mid-America Nazarene | NAIA | |||
| Carl Garrett | Ft. Hays University | NCAA DII | |||
| Kendale Johnson | Metro State University | NCAA DII | |||
| David Schmidt | Ft. Hays University | NCAA DII | |||
| 1990 | Harvey Thompson | University of Hawaii | NCAA DI | ||
| Brad Henry | Emporia State University | NCAA DII | |||
| Jason Steinberg | Florida International | NCAA DI | |||
| Darin Dahl | Metro State - Denver | NCAA DII | |||
| Jerry Elliott | Offer from Northeastern Chicago and University of Missouri-St. Louis | ||||
| Kevin Hall | Rockhurst College | NCAA DII | |||
| Steve Barrick | Southern Utah | NCAA DI | |||
| 1989 | Brian Jones | Tarkio | NAIA | ||
| Stan Bradley | Tennessee Martin | NCAA DII | |||
| Steve Precciely | Bartlesville Wesleyan | NAIA | |||
| Maurice Lamar | Washburn University | NCAA DII | |||
| George Guilbeaux | Friends University | NAIA | |||
| John Watson | Offer from Benedictine | NAIA | |||
| 1988 | Bobby Harris | Central State-Oklahoma | NCAA DII | ||
| Billy Smith | Wayland Baptist | NAIA | |||
| Mike Hynes | Arkansas - Little Rock | NCAA DI | |||
| Donnie Moore | Cameron University | NCAA DII | |||
| Manual Holmes | Offer from St. Mary College | NAIA | |||
| DeWitt Byers | Offer from Avila | NAIA | |||
| Terrance Hughes | Pan American | NCAA DI | |||
| 1987 | Mark McQuillan | Mid-America Nazarene | NAIA | ||
| Louis Jones | N.W. Missouri State | NCAA DII | |||
| Maurice Fields | Benedictine | NAIA | |||
| Derek Covington | Denver University | NCAA DII | |||
| Desmond Clifton | West Virginia | NCAA DI | |||
| Wayland Baptist | NAIA | ||||
| James Davis | Signed at Pan American | NCAA DI |