| Year | Athlete | Honor | Team | |
| 2024 | Maclane Finley | NJCAA | Honorable Mention | |
| Gehrig Goldbeck | NJCAA | ABCA/Rawlings Gold Glove | ||
| 2023 | Gehrig Goldbeck | NJCAA Gold Glove, NJCAA Defensive Player of the Year | ||
| 2019 | Eduardo Acosta | 3rd Team Academic | ||
| Phillip Bryant | 3rd Team Academic | |||
| Christopher Vierra | 3rd Team Academic | |||
| Griffin Everitt | 3rd Team Academic | |||
| Kaleb Harrison | 3rd Team Academic | |||
| Traice Hartter | 2nd Team Academic | |||
| Tyler Henry | 3rd Team Academic | |||
| Jake Martin | 3rd Team Academic | |||
| 2017 | Honorable Mention Team Academic | |||
| Alex Phillips | NJCAA Honorable Mention All-American | |||
| Adam North | 3rd Team All Academic | |||
| Alex Phillips | 3rd Team All Academic | |||
| Chase Redick | 3rd Team All Academic | |||
| Tyler Pittman | 3rd Team All Academic | |||
| Chad Cox | 2nd Team All Academic | |||
| Jacob Purl | 2nd Team All Academic | |||
| Brandon Still | 2nd Team All Academic | |||
| Ty Bradshaw | 1st Team All Academic | |||
| Drew Holtgrieve | 1st Team All Academic | |||
| 2016 | Eli Lovell | NJCAA Honorable Mention All American | ||
| Acedmic All-Americans | ||||
| Drew Holtgrieve | NJCAA Pinnacle Academic Achievement (4.0) | |||
| Avery Fliger | NJCAA Superior Academic Achievement | |||
| Brandon Reid | NJCAA Superior Academic Achievement | |||
| Caleb Gray | NJCAA Superior Academic Achievement | |||
| Chase Redick | NJCAA Superior Academic Achievement | |||
| Daulton Smith | NJCAA Superior Acadmeic Achievement | |||
| Jacob Purl | NJCAA Superior Academic Achievement | |||
| Chad Cox | NJCAA Exemplary Academic Achievement | |||
| Elijah Baig | NJCAA Exemplary Academic Achievement | |||
| Ross Walker | NJCAA Exemplary Academic Achievement | |||
| 2015 | Academic All- Americans | |||
| Tanner Foerschler | NJCAA Exemplary Academic Achievement | |||
| Alex Thrower | NJCAA Exemplary Academic Achievement | |||
| NJCAA All Academic Team (3.26) | ||||
| 2014 | Cole Frakes | NJCAA Superior Academic Achievement (3.82) | ||
| Mitchell Glessner | NJCAA Exemplary Academic Achievement (3.71) | |||
| Luke Norton | NJCAA Superior Academic Achievement (3.85) | |||
| 2013 | Zac Butler | NJCAA Third Team All American | ||
| Andrew Kreiling | NJCAA Superior Academic Achievement (3.9) | |||
| 2005 | Jake Dean | NJCAA Third Team All American |